ʿAlī and the Claim That He Was Appointed First Caliph

Name: ʿAlī and the Claim That He Was Appointed First Caliph
Uploaded: 2026-08-21T00:00:00.000Z
Duration: 5 min 27 s
Description: He argues that accepting the claim that ʿAlī was explicitly appointed first caliph would imply that ʿAlī himself disregarded that instruction for twenty-five years.

حضرت علی رضی اللہ عنہ کو خلیفۂ اول مقرر کرنے کے دعوے کا جواب

Subject: History
Language: Urdu
Length: 5m

He argues that accepting the claim that ʿAlī was explicitly appointed first caliph would imply that ʿAlī himself disregarded that instruction for twenty-five years.

اگر یہ ماں لیا جائے کہ حضور ص نے حضرت علی ر کوخلیفہ اول متعین کر دیا تھا ۔تو حضرت علی ر پر ہی الزام اجائے گا کہ 25 سال تک اس حدیث پر عمل نہیں کیا ۔اور زندگی بھر اس حدیث کے خلاف کرتے رہے ۔ثمیر الدین قاسمی۔انگلینڈ